These cookies were a year in the making... I saw the idea on Pinterest last year and had every intention of making them, I even bought the heart shaped peanut butter cups. But life was rather hectic and crazy last year and it just never got done.
Now that life has settled back into a semi-normal schedule I have been able to cook and bake a lot more so these were going to get done for sure. You make them just like you would regular peanut butter blossoms but substitute a heart shaped candy in place of the kiss. I used Reese's Peanut Butter Cups for an extra peanut buttery taste but these would also be great with a heart shaped Dove chocolate.